An independent show guide not a venue or show. All tickets 100% guaranteed, some are resale, prices may be above face value. We're an independent show guide not a venue or show. We sell primary, discount and resale tickets, all 100% guaranteed prices may be above face value. We are an independent show guide not a venue or show. We sell primary, discount and resale tickets, all 100% guaranteed and they may be priced above or below face value.

Mean Girls Reviews

Broadway ShowsMusicalsDrama Desk WinnersTony NomineesDrama Desk Nominees

Average customer review: 2.5 star rating (2.4 Stars)

Number of reviews: 27

Page:1234All

Sort:

5.0 star rating from Memphis, Tennessee

SO FETCH!

Wow, this show was so funny and absolutely amazing. All the actors were on point and very talented. My first time seeing the show, was definitely not a let down!

5.0 star rating Addi from Greenville, South Carolina

SO AMAZING!!

Was the best night of my week! Definitely worth seeing!! Such amazing acting and voices. As Gretchen would say, it was “fetch!”

5.0 star rating Khieng from Ottawa, Ontario

FETCH IS NOT HAPPENING, BUT THIS IS

The Best Musical I've Seen In A LOONNNG Time, This Is Now One Of My Favorite Musicals, Due To The Acting, Music, And Overall Story Of The Musical

5.0 star rating Anonymous from No

I DON’T KNOW WHAT EVERYONE’S TALKING ABOUT IT WAS AMAZING

It was so amazing! I went with my mom and sister who have seen a bootleg and seen the movie. We were so exited and our expectations were met! The actors were amazing and I don’t know what everyone is saying about Regina she was amazing. Cady was a little high but still amazing. People are also complains about it being to inappropriate and not suit for kids, but , yeah ITS NOT MADE FOR THE YOUNGER AUDIENCE. Check the age rating! Don’t bring your kids to a musical you have never seen or heard. It’s not their fault you won’t check an age rating 🙄. Honestly an amazing show and totally recommend!

4.0 star rating K from Toronto, Ontario

REGINA GEORGE VOICE WAS AWFUL HER VOICE WAS SO TERRIBLE

Liked all the other lead actors. The ensemble good also. Set design colourful and music had good energy. The characters of Cady and Janis ( she was outstanding) Karen and Damian ( both outstanding) and Araron and Regina’s mother and actress who played the school teacher were all great. The male lead Damian was superb . Enjoyed the show though and definitely worth seeing.

3.0 star rating Tina from Stafford, Virginia

SOMEWHAT DISAPPOINTING

I was very excited to go see this show with my daughter, but I'm afraid it seemed more like a high school production acting-wise. It was very loud as one other reviewer noted, and it was hard to understand the words of several of the songs because the music was either too loud, or maybe they were having issues with the mics. That being said, the sets were very clever and the standout performances were from the actors who portrayed Karen and Janice. The theater was very nice and the attendants helping with seating were friendly and welcoming.

3.0 star rating E from Providence, Rhode Island

UNEVEN

I'm actually glad to read other reviewer's complaints about the sound, I thought it was just me. I saw this show in Boston a few years ago and this production is definitely not as strong. The actress who plays Regina is miscast, couldn't understand a thing she sang or spoke and her vocals were just not strong enough for the role. Maybe opening night nerves? The actresses playing Janice and Cady did a great job, and Damian's diction was spot on. Even with the sound issues, I could hear and understand almost everything. Pacing seemed to be an issue, with dialog being run through at lightning speed with no pauses for laughs. As for the orchestra, they did a good job. I was wondering about the booming (like startling) sound at the end of several songs - was that an electric bass guitar that was turned up to 11? Very jarring. The sound in the second half of the show was a bit better, hopefully the team will continue to make adjustments to improve the sound.

3.0 star rating Susan from Toronto, Ontario

LOUD AND SHRILL

Although the premise is great, and enjoyed the movie, I found the singing very disappointing in the stage presentation. Esp Regina and Cady. The second half was better, and sets were nicely done, but music loud for the theatre. Felt bad for the little girl in front of me. A bit too much for her age. Is there a PG warning? Maybe she didn't understand the lyrics anyway.

3.0 star rating AC from Toronto, Ontario

LOUD AND KADY LOOK UP

The music was too loud and made it hard to hear the lyrics and at times made you cover your ears to muffle it. We were in the balcony (dress circle) and all we saw was the top of Cary’s head she never looked up during the performance to include the people up top. Maybe they are use to smaller theatres. Karen character was very good. The play was fun however but could be easily improved.

3.0 star rating Tammy from Toronto, Ontario

COULD BE BETTER

Great sets, flow and songs. Unfortunately the sound was shrill and it was hard to hear the singers. Regina and Cady had ok voices but not great. Also, it was hard to understand what Regina was singing as the words blended in with each other.

2.0 star rating CMD from Richmond, Virginia

AGREE WITH OTHERS

Well, I definitely had a first at this show. It was the first time that I have ever left during intermission. Unfortunately, I agree with some of the other reviewers. The leads were very nasally singers and the actors raced through their lines and the music was super loud and drowned out the singing. My husband and I could not understand anything they were saying and missed all of the jokes. We were not the only ones leaving at intermission and I asked one gentleman why he left and he said the same thing that it was just so loud it was not enjoyable. I thought maybe it was where our seats were on the right orchestra, section A, but he was in the balcony and had the same problem.

2.0 star rating Mary from Toronto, Ontario

MEAN GIRLS

Sadly disappointed by this musical. It did not appear to be the quality I've come to expect from Mirvish productions. Voices were drowned out, scenery very amateurish even for a high school setting, and I like many others couldn't wait for intermission to leave. I've been to many great shows, even good shows, but this one was lacking in every aspect.

2.0 star rating S. Anderson from Toronto, Ontario

DERIVATIVE

Love Tina Fey. Love the movie Mean Girls. The Musical? I left the theatre after the first act. Main reason: Cady and Regina characters sing sharp. Cannot do it. Also. The songs. The songs diminish the promise. W. T. F.

2.0 star rating Samantha from Toronto, Ontario

DISAPPOINTING

As a huge musical fan and a huge Mean Girls fan I was really looking forward to this but the play does not have the fun and heart that you are expecting if you know the movie. Regina and Cady do not have good singing voices - to the point that it is uncomfortable. Janis and Damien (understudy) were good and Karen (understudy) was the best part of the show. Felt like a high school production with an inflated budget. Very disappointed.

2.0 star rating Dave from Toronto, Ontario

FETCH ISN'T GONNA HAPPEN

There was a lot of potential for this to be good, unfortunately, rushed lines and miscasts really ruined my experience of this show. The good - standout performances from the supporting casts, namely Karen (Morgan Ashley Bryant) and Damian (Eric Hoffman). They were able to salvage the show with their good vocals and comedic timing. The bad - Regina (Nadina Hassan) had an awful performance. We couldn't understand 70% of what she was saying, and her high notes were so pitchy that many audience members (including myself) had to cover our ears. I really had high hopes for this, but save your time and money - this isn't worth it.

2.0 star rating Yolanda Savino-Walsh from Toronto, Ontario

MEAN GIRLS

This show has potential but like others we left at intermission. The decibel level was just overwhelming. There were zero Sound Guidelines. An usher said there had been complaints yet deterred the sound management of this crew. Brian Ronan should be made to sit in the Dress Circle for an hour.. A huge disservice to both the kids on that stage working so hard to deliver plus the inner ears of a captive audience. Very disappointing afternoon.

2.0 star rating Jo Cyle from Toronto, Ontario

EAR PIERCING & UNINTELLIGIBLE

You won't understand what anyone is singing - and I grew up watching Mean Girls, so I was at least tuned to what was happening. Oddly, the two lead singers playing Cady and Regina are the hardest to listen to. Cady is shrill and changes her voice entirely in her upper register, suddenly becoming 10 years old. Regina is either mumbling or blowing out your eardrums; there's no in between. It was hard to listen to honestly, often painful. Unfortunately, even if the singers were better, the material just isn't there; the music doesn't have any distinct or memorable melodies or lyrics, and I left the night not remembering a single song. ON A POSITIVE NOTE: Karen was a standout - hilarious. Janis and Damien blended singing and articulation well. And the staging was inventive and entertaining. Mean Girls is alright time if your expectations are subterranean. There are a couple laughs, but ultimately doesn't succeed at being a good musical or sufficiently nostalgic.

2.0 star rating Chris from Toronto, Ontario

SOUND ISSUES AND QUESTIONABLE CAST CHOICES

As many have said, the music was either too loud or singers diction was lacking. I could barely understand a word Regina sang and found her pitchy and screechy. Cady had her moments but she too could be hard to understand and got very nasal in the higher range of her vocals. The set was great but that’s the best I can do. It was better than The Shark is Broken (imho) but not by much. This is the first time I have reviewed any show, which should speak volumes. Sorry to the cast. No doubt you put your hearts and souls into this production, but it missed the mark this time. Onward and upward.

1.0 star rating John the season ticket holder from Houston, Texas

WORST SHOW I’VE SEEN IN A WHILE - AND GAVE ME A HEADACHE

Honestly - it was so loud that it gave me a headache and much of the songs had me wincing in agony. Lead actresses were both nasally; and it was much like an actual high school musical in that it was so bad. So much unnecessary screaming.

1.0 star rating Alecia from Madison, Wisconsin

SADLY DIDSAPOINTED

So disappointed... so much sexual content! A whole song about the middle finger, sitting on dicks, lots of sexually! Be forewared all you parents and grandparents who thought this would be a good show for your daughter. Highly disappointed, this could have been so cute and funny and enjoyable had they left out all the sexually, really bummed they choose to go that route.

1.0 star rating Theater Goer from Greensboro, North Carolina

SOPHOMORIC

Too loud, too vulgar, too amateurish.

1.0 star rating SM from Greensboro, North Carolina

SO DISAPPOINTED

At intermission, my husband, myself and several other couples dashed for the door to go home. We collectively agreed that the main characters voice was so shrill it gave you a headache. I have seen musicals in Germany, England, New York City and San Francisco and loved them. This is the first time I have been at a musical and was bored. I could not wait for intermission to come so I could get out of there! So disappointed.

1.0 star rating Valerie Hartwell from Toronto, Ontario

SEE THE MOVIE INSTEAD!

Left at intermission. Too loud--difficult to understand lyrics! Voices had no "heart". Very "screechy".

1.0 star rating Amina from Toronto, Ontario

DISAPPOINTING

So loud. Couldn't understand what Ragina's actress was singing and her voice was horrid. It was extremely cringy given there were so many young girls in the audience and the content was very sexual and inappropriate for children. Very poor production.

1.0 star rating Lynn from Toronto, Ontario

STAY HOME!

I had to leave BEFORE intermission. The cast was yelling the songs, not singing. The story (?) was disjointed. And it was soooo loud. I went with my daughter who loved the movie but had to leave the play as well. Beyond disappointing. More like traumatizing!! Stay home!

1.0 star rating Randall from Toronto, Ontario

USELESS SOUND MIX

The musician doing the sound mix prioritized the instrumentation over the lyrics, doing such a disservice for the hard working cast. So much of the story is in the lyrics, it’s annoyingly frustrating when they’re unintelligible throughout. I’m sure the sound engineer would think it’s borderline, but it should NEVER be close to borderline. Unlike him, we the audience don’t already know the lyrics and aren’t close enough to lip read. Glad I saw the movie, or I would have had no idea what was going on.

1.0 star rating JPSA from Toronto, Ontario

SEEING IS NOT BELIEVING!

As an avid theatre goer I had great anticipation to see MIrvish’s production of Mean Girls. Despite sitting front row the entire production was fraught with sound issues leaving the lines and vocals incomprehensible and inaudible throughout both acts. Miscasts and mishaps left us all feeling this production was more like a high school production that simply fell short, rather than the excellence I have come to admire and love over decades. Left disappointed and let down. Frankly, UN- FETCHED.

Page:1234All

What you thought

Seen Mean Girls? Loved it? Hated it?

Help your fellow Rochester Theater visitors by leaving the first review. Everyone will love you for it, we promise!

Write a review now

What we thought

fun HYSTERICAL Brilliant

I LOVED every minute of this production!

Tina Fey's acclaimed film Mean Girls has been a huge hit on Broadway in this new HYSTERICAL musical adaptation! The story compares life in high school with that of animals trying to survive in the wild.

Read full review
Nicola Quinn

Nicola Quinn

Nearby

Venue home

Venue home

location

Location

restaurantsDiningRestaurants
hotels

Hotels

Additional Information

seating chart
SeatingSeating map

Spread the word

Sound good to you? Share this page on social media and let your friends know about Mean Girls at Rochester Auditorium Theatre.

Keep up to date

I want email news and updates for events in my area! Read how we protect your data.

Please note: The term Rochester Auditorium Theatre and/or Mean Girls as well as all associated graphics, logos, and/or other trademarks, tradenames or copyrights are the property of the Rochester Auditorium Theatre and/or Mean Girls and are used herein for factual descriptive purposes only. We are in no way associated with or authorized by the Rochester Auditorium Theatre and/or Mean Girls and neither that entity nor any of its affiliates have licensed or endorsed us to sell tickets, goods and or services in conjunction with their events.